Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar movie review: If a plot twist fails to fully catch viewers off guard, outsmart them, and elevate the work to new heights, movies risk being quickly labelled as disappointing. While a well-executed twist can still make us lean forward in our chairs and draw us deeper into the story, people’s widespread exposure to cinema and other content such as true-crime podcasts has made it easier for them to see through twists, making it harder for filmmakers to succeed.

This is where gripping, race-against-time crime thrillers like director Shahad Nilambur’s Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar have an advantage. The script doesn’t rely too heavily on risky twists, instead focusing on the cat-and-mouse game between the culprits and the investigator, creating a heaviness in the viewers’ chests, fostering concern that those they are rooting for might get caught. The tension is further heightened by showing the characters walking on thin ice, with almost nothing in their favour, and avoiding apprehension by a hair’s breadth.

Must Read | Aasha movie review: Urvashi, Joju George anchor a flawed yet compelling drama-thriller

Story continues below.
Subscribe to see fewer ads.

However, what keeps Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar from being an impeccable crime thriller is its convenient writing and resemblance to past movies.

The widow of a martyred police officer, Aleena Abraham (Parvathy Thiruvothu) makes it to the force on compassionate grounds and receives an appointment as a Civil Police Officer (CPO) at the Nattakom station after her training. She slowly settles in, dreaming of giving her in-laws and baby daughter a better life.

One night, while on patrol, she and her fellow officers Sreenath (Mathew Thomas) and Dasan (Sidharth Bharathan) catch a man under suspicious circumstances and bring him to the station, where Divya (Unnimaya Prasad) is the only one on duty. There, a scuffle breaks out between the four officers and the man, resulting in his accidental death. Certain that this will be the end of their lives, the four join forces to cover up the crime and save themselves.

Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar (Prima Facie Guilty) features one of the smartest title placements in recent Malayalam cinema, where its appearance not only adds dramatic weight but also warns the audience that the four can’t simply justify their actions as “self-defence,” and that they need to go to extreme lengths to save themselves.

Story continues below this ad

Instead of loading the opening sequences with too much drama to make us feel sympathetic towards the central four, writers PS Subramanian and Vijesh Thottingal treat the first act as a procedural. They establish that none of them is a Sethurama Iyer or Commissioner’s (1994) Bharathchandran IPS and that they are all slowly building their lives, having not yet reached a comfortable position.

Subramanian and Vijesh keep things light and flesh out the story slowly, giving both the audience and the characters time to settle into the world. However, once the narrative shifts gears, the writers seem clear on how they want to take Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar forward, with no signs of confusion.

Memories of Blunder | Mohanlal masterfully played MGR in Iruvar, then went on to look like his photocopy in a dud

They don’t simply shift to top gear after Harris Meeran (Vijayaraghavan), a highly intelligent crime branch officer, takes over the case; nor do they slip in twists at every turn. Instead, they treat the story like a gripping drama in which a group of powerless people races against time, holding their lives in their hands.

Story continues below this ad

Convenient writing and an underutilised lead investigator

However, Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar’s script starts to feel weak once Subramanian and Vijesh resort to convenient writing, with Aleena finding all the answers and ideas she needs in a police memoir penned by Harris himself. While showing her getting a few tips or the idea to crack the most difficult puzzle in this scenario from the book would have been cool, the movie depicts her as getting all her ideas from it, which makes the script feel flimsy.

What’s even worse is that Harris is often shown making the same moves he made in the past, which he then detailed in his book, rendering the character smaller than others perceive him. While the interval block is impressive and showcases Harris’ sharpness, it turns out to be the only such moment in the movie, diminishing his character’s so-called greatness as a cop.

While Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar is technically strong, the crime thriller desperately needed stronger actors in the central roles. (Credit: Instagram/@pradhamadrishtyakuttakkar)

Surprisingly, the movie has quite a few comedic lines and moments, particularly featuring actor Vinay Forrt’s CI Prathap Mohan, that make one chuckle but suddenly feel out of sync with the film’s overall tone.

While Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar establishes its characters well and fleshes them out properly, that doesn’t justify its unnecessarily long runtime, as the movie could easily have been trimmed to feel tighter.

Story continues below this ad

The undeniable shadow of Drishyam

Also, has Drishyam (2013) left such an impact on Malayalam crime thriller makers that they un/knowingly end up emulating it or incorporating traces of it into their works often? Or has the Jeethu Joseph directorial blinded us so much that we, as audiences, end up seeing shades of it everywhere we look, even when it is merely a hunch?

I honestly don’t know the exact answer, but I believe it’s a mix of both.

Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar reinforces my feelings, as you can easily see traces of Drishyam throughout the movie. From burying the body on police station premises and trying to find a way out through art (if it was movies for Georgekutty, it’s a book for Aleena) to dialogues like “we have only two options now: either surrender or resist,” there are quite a few similarities between the two.

SCREEN Exclusive | ‘Filmmaking may change in 3-4 years due to AI’: Kiran Das on turning director with Unmadham

Story continues below this ad

Yes, one could argue that Drishyam wasn’t the first movie to introduce some of these plot devices. But still, the resemblances are too obvious to ignore. Not just Drishyam; one could even find shades of Martin Prakkat’s Nayattu (2021) in Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar at times, even though not explicitly.

Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar is weighed down by weak performances

While the film is technically strong, the crime thriller desperately needed better actors to play the central roles. Although Parvathy, Mathew, Sidharth, and Unnimaya try their best, the emotional weight and fear they experience never quite resonate because of their unimpressive performances. Unnimaya’s portrayal, in particular, comes across as highly theatrical at times.

Roby Varghese Raj’s cinematography is brilliant, as he often captures the mounting tension sharply in each scene. Particularly impressive are the visuals of the scuffle at the station that leads to the murder. Although Mujeeb Majeed’s music is impressive at times, it doesn’t adequately elevate the thrilling moments.

Cinema Anatomy | How Mammootty stole the screen from Rajinikanth with subtlety, quiet authority in Thalapathi

Story continues below this ad

Also, just a thought: aren’t we increasingly normalising such how-to-get-away-with-murder stories a bit too much? I mean, sure, one could argue that these are underdogs with almost no privilege or power and that the person who died “deserved” it. But in a country where a large section of the population is overly obsessed with cinema and considers what transpires on screen as the “absolute truth” or something to follow blindly, one cannot ignore the possibility of such movies “inspiring them” too much.

Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar movie cast: Parvathy Thiruvothu, Vijayaraghavan, Mathew Thomas, Sidharth Bharathan, Unnimaya Prasad, Azees Nedumangad, Vinay Fortt


Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar movie director: Shahad Nilambur


Pradhama Drishtya Kuttakkar movie rating: 2.5 stars